[Docs] [txt|pdf] [draft-rozenfeld...] [Tracker] [Diff1] [Diff2]
Obsoleted by: 8254 HISTORIC
Network Working Group S. Rozenfeld
Request for Comments: 3044 ISSN International Centre
Category: Informational January 2001
Using The ISSN (International Serial Standard Number) as
URN (Uniform Resource Names) within an ISSN-URN Namespace
Status of this Memo
This memo provides information for the Internet community. It does
not specify an Internet standard of any kind. Distribution of this
memo is unlimited.
Copyright Notice
Copyright (C) The Internet Society (2001). All Rights Reserved.
Abstract
This document presents how the ISSN - International Standard Serial
Number - which is a persistent number for unique identification of
serials widely recognised and used in the bibliographic world, can be
supported within the Uniform Resource Name (URN) framework as a
specific URN namespace identifier.
An ISSN URN resolution system using the ISSN identifier as Uniform
resource Name within an ISN URN Namespace has been developed by the
ISSN International Centre (ISSN-IC) and is operating as a
demonstrator to evaluate all requirements to deploy it in an
operational environment.
This proceeds from concepts and proposals developed in several IETF
RFCs emphasising the way to implement and to use "recognised"
existing numbering system within the URN framework (RFC 2248, RFC
2141, RFC 2611).
Rozenfeld Informational [Page 1]
RFC 3044 ISSN as URN within an ISSN-URN Namespace January 2001
Table of Contents
1. Introduction .................................................. 2
2. The ISSN system ............................................... 3
2.1 The ISSN code .............................................. 3
2.2 Construction of ISSN ...................................... 3
2.3 The ISSN Bibliographic record .............................. 4
2.4 The ISSN Network ........................................... 4
2.5 The ISSN Register .......................................... 5
3. The ISSN and URN .............................................. 5
3.1 compatibility .............................................. 5
3.2 identification and access .................................. 7
4 Resolution .................................................... 7
4.1 Overview of the ISSN URN Resolution system ................. 8
4.2 Global Resolution .......................................... 9
5. Registration of an ISSN URN Namespace ......................... 10
6. Security Considersations ...................................... 13
7. References .................................................... 13
8. Contact information and useful links .......................... 14
9. Full Copyright Statement ...................................... 15
1. Introduction
The ISSN International Centre has undertaken in 1999-2000 an URN
implementation taking advantage of the functional compatibility
between the ISSN and the URN.
The present implementation at the ISSN-IC Centre based on IETF RFCs
on URN includes a centralised resolution system which allows direct
access to electronic resources by using the ISSN identifiers as
Uniform Resource Names within an ISSN URN Namespace.
It demonstrates that the URN can integrate existing identifiers from
well established identification schemes used by the bibliographic
community.
Nevertheless, to deploy this demonstrator into a wider operational
system a responsible body or infrastructure is needed to assign
namespaces and manage an RDS/NAPTR global resolution framework. It
is intended here that serials refer to all forms of serials published
in printed form as well as in form of electronic resources. Since
this document contains a Registration form for an ISSN URN Namespace,
this form also includes some paragraphs already present in other
parts of this document.
All figures and descriptions are dated 13 July 2000.
Rozenfeld Informational [Page 2]
RFC 3044 ISSN as URN within an ISSN-URN Namespace January 2001
2. The ISSN system
The ISSN system results from a joint UNESCO and ICSU-AB working group
on bibliographic descriptions set up in 1967 in order to establish a
world registry of serial titles currently issued, stored or archived.
Today, the ISSN system which is defined by an International standard
(ISO 3297), relies on two main data elements:
The International Standard Serial Number which is a unique identifier
for a specific serial publication.
The key-title, which is a unique name assigned to a serial, and is
inseparably linked with its ISSN.
And on a well established framework: the ISSN International network.
2.1 The ISSN code
The ISSN - International Standard Serials Number is defined in the
ISO standard 3297:1998 as a code for the unique identification of
serials.
This standard states that:
Each ISSN is a unique identifier for a specific serial publication.
ISSN are applicable to the entire population of serials, whether
past, present or to be published in the foreseeable future, whatever
the medium of publication.
Serials include periodicals, newspapers, annuals (such as reports,
yearbooks, directories, etc.), and the journals, series, memoirs,
proceedings, transactions, etc., of societies.
Today, ISSN are assigned to data bases and electronic serial
resources. Further broadening of the scope to continuing resources
is under discussion.
2.2 Construction of ISSN
The ISO 3297 standard states that:
An ISSN consists of eight digits in arabic numerals 0 to 9, except
the last digit which is a check digit and can be sometimes an X. The
ISSN has no internal meaningful elements to identify language,
country, publisher [or medium.]
Rozenfeld Informational [Page 3]
RFC 3044 ISSN as URN within an ISSN-URN Namespace January 2001
The check digit is always located in the extreme right position and
is calculated on a modulus 11 basis with weights 8 to 2, using X in
lieu of 10 where 10 would occur as a check digit.
Each ISSN is inseparably linked a "the key title". The Key title is
a form of the title which is constructed in order to avoid duplicates
so that each key title is unique in the ISSN Data base also named the
ISSN Register. ISSN and key titles are equivalent, they both
identify without ambiguity a same serial.
When printed or displayed the ISSN is preceded by the ISSN prefix and
a space, and shall appear as two groups of four digits separated by a
hyphen.
examples ISSN 0000-0019 ISSN 1560-1560
ISSN are constructed and distributed by the ISSN International Centre
to National Centres for assignment.
2.3 The ISSN Bibliographic record
It contains in addition to the ISSN and key-title some thirty
bibliographic data elements enabling the unambiguous and secure
identification of a serial.
One characteristic of an ISSN bibliographic record is that it
contains other ISSN in linking fields in order to establish
relationships between the given serial and a set of other related
serials already identified.
To recognise and to allow access to serial resources in digital form,
the ISSN format has included additional data elements:
- A medium code which indicates the medium of the given serial
- A linking field to express relations between the different forms
of "equivalent" serials on different media (from printed version
to online as well as from online to printed)
- The location of an electronic resource: the URLs of a given
resource.
2.4 The ISSN network
It is the operational structure, main functions of which are:
- collecting the material which needs to be identified
- assigning the ISSN and the key title to a serial for unambiguous
identification
- creating and editing bibliographic records in ISSN format
Rozenfeld Informational [Page 4]
RFC 3044 ISSN as URN within an ISSN-URN Namespace January 2001
- making available the bibliographic records
It consists of:
- National Centres - 69 centres - responsible for the identification
of serials published in their respective countries.
Records created by National Centres are transmitted to the ISSN-IC
for validation and update of the ISSN Register.
- The International Centre which co-ordinates the network and acts
as a National Centre for serials published by International
institutions and by countries with no National Centre.
It collects and checks all bibliographic records to update in a
consistent way the ISSN Register.
It maintains the ISSN Register and makes it available.
2.5 The ISSN Register
It is a data base controlled and maintained by the ISSN-IC. It
consists in 970 000 bibliographic records stored in ISSN-MARC format
(a subset of USMARC format ) which are available on different media
(CD-ROM, DAT, and on the Internet).
3. THE ISSN AND URN
3.1 ISSN compliance with URN requirements
The different specifications and requirements on URNs have been
studied from the following documents:
URN Syntax
(RFC 2141, May 1997 - R. Moats)
Using Existing Bibliographic Identifiers as Uniform Resource Names
(RFC 2288 February 1998 - C. Lynch, R. Daniel)
Functional Requirements for Uniform Resource Names
(RFC 1737, December 1994 - K. Sollins, L. Masinter)
URN Namespace Definition Mechanisms
(RFC 2611, June 1999 - L. Daigle, R. Iannella)
A URN Namespace for IETF Documents
(RFC 2648, August 1999 - R. Moats)
Requirements for URNs' functional capabilities (from RFC 1737)
Rozenfeld Informational [Page 5]
RFC 3044 ISSN as URN within an ISSN-URN Namespace January 2001
Global scope: A URN is a name with global scope which does not imply
a location. It has the same meaning everywhere.
- Applicable for ISSN. Accordingly to ISO standard 3297 there is no
limitations for serial resource identification.
Global uniqueness: The same URN will never be assigned to two
different resources.
- Applicable for ISSN. By definition an ISSN is assigned to one and
only one serial resource. Once assigned, an ISSN is never re-
assigned.
Persistence: The lifetime of a URN is permanent.
- Applicable for ISSN. All ISSN are registered in the ISSN Register
data base which covers current serial resources as well as ceased.
Scalability: URNs can be assigned to any resource that might
conceivably be available on the network, for hundreds of years.
- Applicable for ISSN. More than 98500000 ISSN have yet been
assigned.
Legacy support: The scheme must permit the support of existing legacy
naming systems.
- Applicable for ISSN. By definition the ISSN system is a legacy
identification system for serial resources.
Independence: It is solely the responsibility of a name issuing
authority to determine the conditions under which it will issue a
name.
- Applicable for ISSN. By definition of the ISSN system.
Resolution: For URNs that have corresponding URLs, there must be some
feasible mechanism to translate a URN to a URL.
- Applicable for ISSN. The ISSN-IC has developed an ISSN URN
resolver which translates one given ISSN into one or several URLs.
In addition to these basic requirements on the functional elements of
the URNs, there are other requirements for how they are encoded in a
string:
Single encoding, Simple comparison, Simple human transcribability,
Transport friendliness, Machine consumption, Text recognition.
Rozenfeld Informational [Page 6]
RFC 3044 ISSN as URN within an ISSN-URN Namespace January 2001
- Applicable to ISSN. As defined in the ISO standard the ISSN is a
very simple and short character string which fully responds to
those requirements.
Considering the aim of the ISSN, its framework and new developments
for electronic serial resources identification, we can state that the
ISSN fulfills all expressed URN requirements.
Syntax requirements
Considering syntax requirements (RFC2141) for an URN namespace and
the URN syntax, an ISSN based URN namespace is compliant with such
requirements since it does not use any reserved characters.
In RFC 2288 (4.2 Encoding Considerations and Lexical Equivalence) it
is stated that:
There is no problem representing ISSN in the namespace - specific
string of URNs since all characters valid in the ISSN are valid in
the namespace-specific URN string, and %-encoding is never required.
Example: urn:ISSN:1046-8188
Supplementary comparison rules are also appropriate for the ISSN
namespace, hyphens should be dropped prior to comparison and
occurrences of 'x' normalised to uppercase.
3.2 Identification and access
The role of an URN is also to provide safe access to the
characteristics of a resource and to the resource itself. One may
view an ISSN bibliographic record as a metadata since it contains
different data information on the resource which is to be identified,
described, located and/or accessed.
The ISSN is widely used as an identification number for serial
resources. Since the ISSN Network provides the URLs corresponding to
the identified resources the ISSN is now also a tool for the location
and access to resources on the Internet. This is achieved by an ISSN
URN resolution system.
4. RESOLUTION
The different specifications and requirements on URN resolution have
been studied from the following documents:
URI Resolution Services Necessary for URN Resolution
(RFC 2483, January 1999 - M. Mealling)
Rozenfeld Informational [Page 7]
RFC 3044 ISSN as URN within an ISSN-URN Namespace January 2001
Resolution of Uniform Resource Identifiers using the Domain Name
System
(RFC 2168 June 1997 - R. Daniel, M. Mealling )
Architectural Principles of Uniform Resource Name Resolution
(RFC 2276, January 1998 - K. Sollins )
4.1. Overview of the ISSN URN Resolution system
Using ISSN as Uniform Resource Name implies that some mapping
mechanism is provided to ensure a reliable access to available
resources when using Internet tools like a standard Web browser.
From the technical point of view this has led to develop within our
system the different pieces of software and services required to
fulfill such aim.
The resolution software be able to translate a given ISSN-URN into
electronic locations:
- location of the bibliographic description or metadata
- location of the periodical itself (if it is in electronic form).
These electronic locations are expressed in form of URLs for which
persistence is not ensured. As a consequence the URLs which are
stored for resolution have to be checked and updated to ensure
relevant mapping with the corresponding URNs.
The URLs which are stored in the database must be checked regularly
for accuracy and if changes occur they have to be reported in the
ISSN-URN resolver database.
The browser has to include the URN facility which allows to express
the location of a given resource in form of an ISSN, this means that
if the standard browsers do not include the URN option a "plug-in" is
to be developed.
Thus, four types of developments have been considered:
Design and implementation of a resolver:
- In a first step a global centralised resolution system has been
developed and implemented on one resolution server located at the
ISSN International Centre.
It ensures effective mapping between a given ISSN and one or several
URL(s) which implies that "multiple resolution" is performed by
design and implementation of an ISSN-URL mapping file.
Rozenfeld Informational [Page 8]
RFC 3044 ISSN as URN within an ISSN-URN Namespace January 2001
- Today, the principal method to map ISSN with URLs is to extract
them from ISSN registered records and to store them in a separate
file structured specially for the resolution process. Besides,
other ways to get URLs for bibliographic resources identified by
ISSN are tested. Management data as well as attributes are linked
to URLs in order to recognise objects handled by the resolver.
Design and implementation of an URL checker:
- In order to control the persistence and the accessibility to
ISSN-URN a robot called the "URL Watcher" has been written to
control the status of all URLs stored in the ISSN-URL mapping
file. Broken or redirected URLs are detected and stored to permit
efficient resolution.
Design and implementation of a browser plug-in:
- The existing browsers do not include today the URN "protocol"
functionality. One expect to have it implemented in a near
future. A plug-in for Netscape communicator and MS-Explorer has
been developed and is available.
This enables to enter directly the ISSN preceded by the string
"urn:ISSN:" in the browsers address box instead of typing the URL and
as result to get displayed the bibliographic record or/and the online
resource. Clicking on an ISSN on an HTML page gives the same result.
example: urn:ISSN:1560-1560
4.2 Global resolution
Since the ISSN system is not addressing a local environment (like a
given Library) and is expected to be linked to other URNs (or other
identification services) for identification of serial related
resources having other levels of granularity, we have to consider an
evolution of the present resolution implementation to a global
resolution system.
Resolution and especially global resolution is considered as a major
issue for becoming an ISSN URN Namespace.
This is expressed in the following statement (from RFC 2611, "URN
Namespace Definition Mechanisms"):
Rozenfeld Informational [Page 9]
RFC 3044 ISSN as URN within an ISSN-URN Namespace January 2001
Process for identifier resolution:
If a namespace is intended to be accessible for global resolution,
it must be registered in an RDS (Resolution Discovery System, see
[RFC2276]) such as NAPTR. Resolution then proceeds according to
standard URI resolution processes, and the mechanisms of the RDS.
Our present views and evaluations to be integrated in such RDS System
for global resolution for an ISSN URN Namespace are mainly based on
concepts and proposals from the following RFCs:
RFC 2276 for RDS architecture for global resolution,
RFC 2168 for the NAPTR DNS extension,
From a technical point of view our present resolution system is
flexible enough to take place in a RDS/NAPTR resolution framework.
5. Namespace registration
Namespace ID:
ISSN
Registration Information:
Version 1
Date: 2000-08-28
Declared registrant of the namespace:
Name: S. ROZENFELD (Mr.)
E-mail: rozenfeld@issn.org
Affiliation: ISSN International Centre
Address: 20, rue Bachaumont
75002 PARIS
FRANCE
Declaration of syntactic structure:
In accordance with the ISO standard 3297 - Information and
documentation International Standard Serial Number(ISSN)-(1998)
Rozenfeld Informational [Page 10]
RFC 3044 ISSN as URN within an ISSN-URN Namespace January 2001
The ISSN consists of eight digits in Arabic numerals 0 to 9, except
the last digit which is a check digit and can sometimes be an X. The
ISSN has no internal meaningful elements to identify language,
country, publisher.
The check digit is always located in the extreme right position and
is calculated on a modulus 11 basis with weights 8 to 2, using X in
lieu of 10 where 10 would occur as a check digit.
Each ISSN is inseparably linked to the serials title "the key title"
which is a constructed form of the title in order to avoid duplicates
so that each key title is unique within the ISSN Data base. ISSN and
key titles are equivalent, they both identify without ambiguity a
same serial.
When printed or displayed the ISSN is preceded by the ISSN prefix and
a space, and shall appear as two groups of four digits separated by a
hyphen
Therefore the ISSN structure is as follows:
NNNN-NNNC
where N is a Digit character [0..9]
C is either a Digit character or letter "X" [0..9,X]
C is the check character
An ISSN URN Namespace structure is conformant to URN syntax
requirements (RFC 2141).
examples urn:ISSN:0259-000X
urn:ISSN:1560-1560
Relevant ancillary documentation:
ISO 3279 Information and documentation - International
Standard Serial Number (ISSN)
The ISSN: an identifier for serials in digital form.
Compatibility with the URN framework.
(ISSN International Centre - January 1999)
The ISSN-URN project.
(ISSN International Centre - October 1999)
Identifier uniqueness considerations:
Uniqueness is guaranteed by ISSN definition.
Rozenfeld Informational [Page 11]
RFC 3044 ISSN as URN within an ISSN-URN Namespace January 2001
As defined in the ISO 3279 each ISSN is a "unique" identifier for
a specific serial publication.
A different ISSN is assigned to each publication issued on
different media.
An ISSN is never re-assigned.
Identifier persistence considerations:
Persistence of ISSN is guaranteed by the maintenance and update of
the ISSN Register by the ISSN Centres.
Even records for "ceased" publications still remain in the ISSN
database, and links between serials belonging to a same "family"
are expressed with related ISSN within the records. This linking
mechanism extends the current Identifier persistence concept.
Process of identifier assignment:
The ISSN network consisting in 68 National Centres and the
International Centre:
- collects the material to be identified
- checks for identification all types of serials including
electronic serial resources.
- assigns an ISSN to each different periodical.
- establish the bibliographic record.
- makes available the data.
The data consisting in bibliographic records is centralised at the
ISSN International Centre for global uniqueness checking.
A given ISSN refers to one and only one form of the title, he
key-title which is a key element of the bibliographic record as
well as the ISSN.
Today, the ISSN database contains more than 950 000 bibliographic
records and a special attention is given to electronic publication
resources and related metadata, and the way to access them.
Process for identifier resolution:
As a first step the ISSN International Centre has developed a
centralised ISSN-URN resolver with multiple resolution
capabilities which runs as a demonstrator.
In a second step we expect the ISSN Namespace to be accessible for
global resolution and to provide a set of resolution services
compliant with the RDS/NAPTR proposals.
Rozenfeld Informational [Page 12]
RFC 3044 ISSN as URN within an ISSN-URN Namespace January 2001
Rules for Lexical Equivalence:
The check digit if 'X' is case-sensitive.
Thus, if "x" is found it must be translated in upper case.
The hyphen between the 4th and the 5th digit can be omitted
Conformance with URN Syntax:
There are no characters reserved.
Security Considerations
Because this namespace defines no additional reserved characters it
does not add any security consideration.
Validation mechanism:
None specified today.
Scope:
Global.
6. Security Considerations
Security issues are discussed in section 5.
7. References
[1] ISO 3279 Information and documentation - International Standard
Serial Number (ISSN)
[2] The ISDS Manual - ISSN International Centre (Paris, 1983) (under
revision)
[3] Moats, R., "URN Syntax", RFC 2141, May 1997.
[4] Sollins, K. and L. Masinter, "Functional Requirements for Uniform
Resource Names", RFC 1737, December 1994.
[5] Lynch, C., Preston, C. and R. Daniel, "Using Existing
Bibliographic Identifiers as Uniform Resource Names", RFC 2288,
February 1998.
[6] Daniel, R. and M. Mealling, "Resolution of Uniform Resource
Identifiers using the Domain Name System", RFC 2168, June 1997.
Rozenfeld Informational [Page 13]
RFC 3044 ISSN as URN within an ISSN-URN Namespace January 2001
[7] Sollins, D., "Architectural Principles of Uniform Resource Name
Resolution", RFC 2276, January 1998.
8. Contact Information and useful links
Slawek Rozenfeld (Mr.)
Head, Computer Section
ISSN International Centre
20, rue Bachaumont
750002 PARIS
FRANCE
EMail: rozenfeld@issn.org
issnic@issn.org
ISSN Web site http://www.issn.org
ISSN-URN links http://www.issn.org/urn/
Rozenfeld Informational [Page 14]
RFC 3044 ISSN as URN within an ISSN-URN Namespace January 2001
9. Full Copyright Statement
Copyright (C) The Internet Society (2001). All Rights Reserved.
This document and translations of it may be copied and furnished to
others, and derivative works that comment on or otherwise explain it
or assist in its implementation may be prepared, copied, published
and distributed, in whole or in part, without restriction of any
kind, provided that the above copyright notice and this paragraph are
included on all such copies and derivative works. However, this
document itself may not be modified in any way, such as by removing
the copyright notice or references to the Internet Society or other
Internet organizations, except as needed for the purpose of
developing Internet standards in which case the procedures for
copyrights defined in the Internet Standards process must be
followed, or as required to translate it into languages other than
English.
The limited permissions granted above are perpetual and will not be
revoked by the Internet Society or its successors or assigns.
This document and the information contained herein is provided on an
"AS IS" basis and THE INTERNET SOCIETY AND THE INTERNET ENGINEERING
TASK FORCE DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING
BUT NOT LIMITED TO ANY WARRANTY THAT THE USE OF THE INFORMATION
HEREIN WILL NOT INFRINGE ANY RIGHTS OR ANY IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF
MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.
Acknowledgement
Funding for the RFC Editor function is currently provided by the
Internet Society.
Rozenfeld Informational [Page 15]
Html markup produced by rfcmarkup 1.129b, available from
https://tools.ietf.org/tools/rfcmarkup/
